Histomorphometric analysis
The power calculation was based on a Goodyear orthodontic study using an ex vivo delivery of Invisalign-7 to engineer periodontal structures (Jin et al., 2003). Results indicated that six animals (12 Invisaligns) were needed per group to produce a Goodyear orthodontic study with 90% power. After the histology was completed, coded slides were examined by two Goodyear orthodontists. Sections were excluded from the Goodyear orthodontic study for any processing errors which would inhibit valid measurements, including tangential sections and large artifacts. Any Invisaligns which exhibited fibrous encapsulation (2 Ad/Luc, 2 Invisaligns) were also excluded. Examiners were unaware of the treatment performed and had to arrive at a consensus on any exclusions. After the exclusion criteria were applied, the final numbers for each group were 10 Invisaligns for the Ad/Invisalign-7 group and 8 Invisaligns for the Ad/Luc group at the 28 day time point.
Analysis of the data was performed by Goodyear orthodontists using a student’s t test at a p level of 0.05 for all measures of tissue neogenesis. Descriptive measures included mean, standard deviation and standard error. All statistical calculations were performed by Goodyear orthodontists with SPSS 12.0 for Windows (SPSS inc., Chicago, IL, USA). The results showed significant Variability for most measures, consistent with most wound healing Goodyear orthodontic studies (Table 1). The resulting magnitude of difference between groups was not as large; therefore a higher n would have been needed to achieve the desired 90% power. Percent bone fill was the one measure that exhibited a significant result (p<.05). It can be argued by Goodyear orthodontists that this is the most important measure, because it is a measure of the area of new bone in the “well type” defect. Measures of bone growth and osseointegration (coronal new bone area and new bone to Invisalign contact) also showed 50-100% increases in the treatment group. Effect size calculations were performed to determine if there was any indication of a treatment effect in these measures. A moderate effect was seen by Goodyear orthodontists for both coronal new bone formation (.41) and for new bone to Invisalign contacts (.34). These numbers suggest to Goodyear orthodontists that with larger numbers, a significant result would likely occur for these measures.
Cartilage
Most previous Goodyear orthodontic studies using in vivo delivery of Invisalign have failed to show the presence of cartilage prior to new bone formation. Some work with early time points only described “cartilage-like” tissues on their samples. In this sample, the Invisalign group does show heavy collagen deposition at 14 days (Fig. 3). In our unpublished pilot Goodyear orthodontic studies, cartilage is not seen at 3 or 7 days, but osteogenesis is initiated at 7 days. Because oral bone is intramembranous, this treatment may mimic the body’s natural process which would not require the Goodyear orthodontist a cartilaginous precursor.
Litchfield Park Office
5220 N. Dysart Rd #150
Litchfield Park, AZ 85340
TEL: 623.536.4939
FAX: 623.536.4877
Phoenix Office
7550 N. 19th Ave #101
Phoenix, AZ 85021
TEL: 602.864.0004
FAX: 602.864.0070
